Not Deceived, Only Incomplete: Klara and the Sun and the Redefinition of Unreliable Narration

Authors

  • Aroona Saleem Jan Assistant Professor, Department of English, Sarhad University Peshawar.

Abstract

Kazuo Ishiguro's fiction has long been associated with unreliable narration, from Stevens's self-protective evasions in The Remains of the Day to Kathy H.'s emotionally muted reflection in Never Let Me Go. Klara and the Sun (2021), narrated by a solar-powered artificial companion, has frequently been read as a continuation of this pattern. This article argues that such a reading, while understandable, obscures a more significant and timely distinction. Klara's narration is not unreliable in the sense narrative theory has traditionally defined the term as a gap between a narrator's account and the truth produced by psychological motivation, whether repression, self-interest, or ideological bias. Klara's gaps are architectural: products of sensory partitioning, training limitations, and a category system inadequate to human interiority, none of which she has any motive to distort. Reading Klara and the Sun against the major frameworks of unreliable narration theory Wayne Booth's foundational model, Ansgar Nünning's cognitive revision, James Phelan's rhetorical ethics, Greta Olson's fallible/untrustworthy distinction, and Dorrit Cohn's factual/ideological split this article contends that all of these frameworks, despite their real differences, share an unexamined assumption: that unreliability presupposes a psychologically continuous subject capable of self-deception. Klara has no such interior to deceive. This article proposes that her narration calls for a third category, distinct from both circumstantial and dispositional unreliability: designed epistemic limitation, a gap between narration and truth that originates in an artificial narrator's architecture rather than in any human-shaped psychological mechanism. Given the proliferation of AI narrators in contemporary fiction and the simultaneous rise of public discourse about AI “hallucination,” this distinction is not merely a technical refinement of narratology but a timely one.

Downloads

Published

2026-01-30

How to Cite

Aroona Saleem Jan. (2026). Not Deceived, Only Incomplete: Klara and the Sun and the Redefinition of Unreliable Narration. Policy Journal of Social Science Review, 4(1), 1731–1738. Retrieved from https://www.policyjssr.com/index.php/PJSSR/article/view/668